If your workers’ comp claim is being contested, sooner or later you will hear the letters ANCR. They stand for accident, notice and causal relationship, the three things that must be proven before a New York workers’ compensation claim is established. Until they are, the insurance carrier generally does not have to pay you anything.
This post explains what each one means, how carriers attack them, and what you can do to protect your claim.
ANCR in plain terms
- Accident: something happened at work, or because of work, that injured you. A repetitive-motion injury or an occupational disease can qualify; it does not have to be a single event.
- Notice: your employer was told about it in time. The law calls for written notice within 30 days of the accident.
- Causal relationship: a doctor connects your injury to the accident or exposure.
If the carrier accepts all three, there is no fight and the claim moves on to the medical and lost-time issues. If it contests any of them, the case goes to an ANCR hearing.
Accident: did it happen, and was it work-related?
Section 10 of the Workers’ Compensation Law covers injuries that arise out of and in the course of employment. In practice, carriers contest the accident in a few predictable ways:
- It did not happen. No witness, no incident report, or a story that changed between the emergency room and the claim form.
- It happened, but not at work. A weekend, a gym, a prior job.
- It happened at work, but not in the course of work. A lunch break off premises, the commute, horseplay, a personal errand.
- It is not an accident at all. For gradual conditions, the carrier may argue normal aging rather than the job. That is where an occupational disease or repetitive-stress theory comes in.
Consistency is the best protection. The emergency room or urgent care record, the doctor’s first report, the claim form and your testimony should all describe the same event. Where a worker is found injured or dead at work and nobody saw what happened, Section 21 of the law presumes the injury arose out of the employment unless the carrier proves otherwise. For conditions that develop over time, see our page on occupational disease claims.
Notice: did you tell the employer in time?
Section 18 of the Workers’ Compensation Law calls for written notice to the employer within 30 days of the accident. Missing that deadline can bar the claim, but the Board can excuse it when:
- the employer, or a supervisor, knew about the accident;
- the notice could not have been given for some good reason; or
- the employer was not prejudiced by the delay.
Most notice disputes come down to the first one. You told the foreman, the foreman says you never did. That is why a short written notice, a text or an email to your supervisor that says what happened and when, is worth more than anything you can say at a hearing a year later. Keep a copy.
Occupational diseases have their own, longer rule. Notice is due within two years after you became disabled and knew, or should have known, that the condition was caused by your work.
Do not confuse notice with filing. Notice goes to the employer. The claim itself is filed with the Workers’ Compensation Board, and that has its own two-year deadline.
Causal relationship: does the medical evidence connect the injury to work?
Causal relationship is decided on medical opinion, and it is where most contested claims are actually won or lost. Your treating doctor has to say, in a report, that your injury was caused by the work accident or exposure. Saying it is “possibly” related is not enough; the opinion has to be stated as a probability, and it should rest on an accurate history.
The carrier will usually answer with its own doctor, an independent medical examiner, who says the condition is degenerative, pre-existing or caused by something else. The judge weighs the two opinions, and the more consistent and better-explained report tends to win.
- Tell your doctor exactly how you were hurt. A history that says only “back pain” with no mention of the lift, fall or crash gives the carrier its argument.
- Mention every body part at the first visits. A knee that first shows up in the records three months later is much harder to connect.
- Be honest about prior injuries. A pre-existing condition is not fatal. If the job aggravated, accelerated or activated it, the claim can be established. Hiding it is what does the damage.
- Keep treating. Gaps in treatment are read as recovery.
The Board will not move a contested claim forward until there is a medical report in the file that connects the injury to work. Our page on denied workers’ comp claims explains how to check for that.
What an ANCR hearing looks like
When the carrier contests the claim, the Board schedules a pre-hearing conference. The carrier has to list its defenses and the witnesses it intends to call, and a defense it does not raise is generally waived. The judge then sets the case down for testimony and medical evidence:
- You testify about the accident, your job and who you told.
- The employer may produce a supervisor or another witness, often on the notice issue.
- The doctors’ opinions on causation come in by report, and if either side asks, by deposition.
- The judge rules on accident, notice and causal relationship, and on which body parts the claim covers.
If the judge finds in your favor, the claim is “established,” and benefits can be awarded back to the start of your lost time. Additional body parts can be added later with medical evidence. If the judge rules against you, there is a deadline to appeal, which our denied claims page covers. Most of these hearings are held by video; see what happens at your hearing.
While ANCR is being decided
The weeks or months a contested claim takes are the hardest part. The carrier is usually not paying, and the comp doctor may be reluctant to treat. Use your private health insurance if you have it, apply for disability benefits through your employer’s plan if you are out of work, and do not stop treating. Your health insurer will be paid back from the comp case once the claim is established.
Frequently asked questions
What does ANCR mean in workers’ comp?
ANCR stands for accident, notice and causal relationship. They are the three things an injured worker must prove before a New York workers’ compensation claim is established: that a work-related accident or exposure happened, that the employer was given timely notice, and that the injury was caused by it.
What is an ANCR hearing?
When the insurance carrier contests a claim, the judge holds hearings on those three issues. The injured worker testifies, the employer may call a supervisor or other witness, and the doctors’ opinions on causation are taken by report or deposition. If the judge finds in the worker’s favor, the claim is established for the body parts proven.
Is telling my supervisor enough notice?
Often, yes. The law calls for written notice within 30 days, but the Board can excuse late or missing written notice when the employer or a supervisor knew about the accident, or when the employer was not harmed by the delay. Put it in writing anyway.
What is the notice deadline for an occupational disease?
For an occupational disease, notice is due within two years after you became disabled and knew, or should have known, that the condition was caused by your work.
What if I had a prior injury to the same body part?
A pre-existing condition does not defeat a claim. If work aggravated, accelerated or activated the condition, the claim can be established. The question becomes how much of the resulting disability is related to work, which can affect apportionment later.
Do I get paid while ANCR is being decided?
Usually not by the carrier. Once the claim is established, benefits can be awarded back to the start of the lost time. In the meantime, keep treating, using private health insurance if you have it.
Talk to a New York workers’ compensation attorney
The Law Offices of Frank J. Dito, Jr. handles workers’ compensation claims from the office on Staten Island, for injured workers throughout the five boroughs and across New York State.
Call 718.701.2776 or 800.310.5520. Consultations are free. If we don’t recover money for you, we don’t get paid.